Jewellery is often among a person’s most treasured possessions, combining financial value with personal and sentimental significance. Yet changes in the market can mean that an outdated insurance valuation no longer reflects the cost of replacing an item today. As a rule, valuations should be updated every 2-3 years, with some categories reviewed yearly.
The importance of a professional valuation
An accurate, up to date valuation provides an essential foundation for appropriate insurance cover. Without one, owners may find themselves underinsured and facing a financial shortfall should an item be lost, stolen or damaged. Equally, an outdated valuation may overstate an item's current replacement value.
A professional valuation goes beyond establishing a monetary figure. It provides a detailed record of an item's characteristics, including its materials, gemstones, craftsmanship, condition and, where relevant, provenance. This information can prove particularly beneficial when identifying an item or establishing an appropriate replacement in the event of a claim.
The valuation process may also highlight signs of wear, loose stone settings or other issues requiring attention, helping protect jewellery over the longer term.
Professional qualifications and accreditation provide important reassurance when selecting a jewellery valuer. Bodies such as the Institute of Registered Valuers and The Gemological Association of Great Britain promote professional standards in valuation practice, including expertise, accuracy and detailed documentation. A comprehensive valuation prepared by an appropriately qualified specialist can also provide valuable supporting evidence in the event of an insurance claim, helping insurers and loss adjusters assess an item and its replacement value.
Specialist knowledge also enables a more informed assessment of gemstones, treatments, documentation and the factors influencing an item's value. Where necessary, further gemological testing or independent laboratory verification may be recommended.
Understanding changes in the jewellery market
The value of jewellery is influenced by a range of factors, from precious metal prices and currency movements to changing consumer demand, rarity and the availability of comparable pieces.
Importantly, these changes do not affect every category of jewellery in the same way. While some pieces may have appreciated considerably, others may have remained stable or declined in value. For those whose insurance figures are based on an original purchase price or an older valuation, there may be a significant difference between the recorded value and the current cost of replacement.
Several areas of the market merit particular attention.
Diamonds
The diamond market has experienced considerable changes in recent years, with prices influenced by global demand, supply and developments in the market for laboratory-grown diamonds. Having initially shown traction, the lab-grown market has significantly decreased in recent years.
While natural classic round brilliants suffered a 30-35% value drop before stabilising in 2026, fancy shapes (such as oval, emerald, cushion, pear, and princess) proved somewhat more resilient.
2026 has seen a major shift toward heritage styles, driving a 25-30% price surge for authentic antique old mine cuts. The natural fancy coloured diamond (investment-grade pinks, blues, and vivid yellows) continues an uninterrupted upward trajectory to command record-breaking auction premiums. Values can vary significantly according to a diamond's carat weight, cut, colour, clarity and whether it is natural or laboratory-grown. Larger or particularly rare stones may also behave differently from the wider market.
For diamond jewellery owners, an updated professional valuation can help establish an appropriate replacement value based on current market conditions.
Precious metals
Between 2020 and 2026, gold experienced unprecedented price growth. Gold and other precious metals represent an important component of the value of many jewellery pieces.
Movements in precious metal prices, together with exchange rates and manufacturing costs, can influence the cost of replacing jewellery, particularly pieces with a substantial metal content.
Sapphires and coloured gemstones
The market for fine coloured gemstones is highly specialised, with values influenced by factors including origin, colour, quality, rarity and whether a stone has undergone treatment.
Exceptional natural sapphires, particularly those with desirable colour and documented origin, can command significant premiums. However, values vary considerably between individual stones. Blue sapphires remain by far the best seller in the coloured gemstone market, with the finer grade sapphires such as Burmese and Ceylon continuing to increase dramatically in value.
Accurate identification and appropriate documentation are therefore particularly important. A specialist valuation can help establish the characteristics of a gemstone and assess its current replacement value, with additional laboratory testing where required.
Designer and signed jewellery
Jewellery by established houses such as Cartier, Bulgari, Chopard, Boodles and Tiffany & Co. can attract particular interest, especially where pieces are rare, discontinued or associated with significant periods in a designer's history.
For insurance purposes, it's important to consider the appropriate basis of replacement. Where a particular design is no longer available, a specialist valuer can advise on the relevant market and potential replacement options, taking into account insurance arrangements.
Vintage and collectable watches
The market for vintage and collectable watches is similarly nuanced, and certain rare and highly sought-after models can command substantial premiums, for example Rolex sports models or Patek Philippe Nautilus and Aquanaut models.
Factors such as originality, condition, provenance, rarity and the presence of original documentation and boxes can all influence value.
For important watch collections, regular specialist valuations can help ensure that insurance figures reflect current market conditions rather than historic purchase prices or previous price booms due to periods of heightened demand.
Protection through regular valuations
Jewellery valuations should not be regarded as a one-off exercise. As markets evolve, the cost of replacing an item can change, sometimes significantly.
A periodic review of valuations, particularly following substantial market movements, significant acquisitions or changes to a collection, is a practical way to help reduce the risk of underinsurance.
The appropriate frequency will depend on the nature of the collection, market conditions and the requirements of the insurer.
Ultimately, a professional valuation provides more than a figure for an insurance schedule. It offers greater clarity about possessions and helps ensure that important and often irreplaceable items are documented and appropriately protected.
Gurr Johns is one of Ecclesiastical’s preferred suppliers. They have significant experience and expertise in conducting valuations for private clients and public institutions, as well as advising on sales and purchases of jewellery, fine art, and valuables. Gurr Johns has a reputation for quality, service, and discretion.
Disclaimer
This article is provided for information purposes and is general and educational in nature. Nothing constitutes legal advice. You are free to choose whether or not to use it, and it should not be considered a substitute for seeking professional legal help in specific circumstances. You acknowledge that over time, this article may become out of date and may not constitute best market practice.
Any third parties listed within this article are for information only, and Ecclesiastical is not endorsing the quality of service which any third party may or may not provide.
Where this article contains links to other sites and resources provided by third parties, these links are provided for your information only. Ecclesiastical is not responsible for the contents of those sites or resources.
Canada
Ireland